Call the Critic Only When the Agent Is Unsure: Gate Verification on Action Uncertainty

Source reports ~3.1x normalized token efficiency on ALFWorld vs a ReAct-comparable budget, and a small actor + small critic matching a 2x-larger actor (validate on your own tasks) Advanced 4 min read

A common reliability pattern for long-horizon agents is to run an expensive critic/verifier model after every step - which roughly doubles token spend even though most steps are unambiguous and gain nothing from a second opinion. Instead, read two cheap uncertainty signals from the actor's own next-action distribution - global entropy and the top-2 logit margin - to approximate the Value of Information of a critique, and invoke the critic only on the genuinely ambiguous steps. Let the actor internalize the critic's guidance over the run so the calls taper off as it improves.

๐Ÿ”’ Pro tip ยท Advanced

Unlock this tip โ€” and 140 more

This is one of 141 advanced, fact-checked tactics reserved for Pro. Get the full 163-tip library, a searchable archive, and a new tip every morning. Free for 7 days, then $9/mo.

Prefer to browse? The 22 Beginner tips are free forever.